I've said it before and I'll say it again: I've got the worst lashes ever. They are fine and short and it takes a lot of time and effort to bulk them up. My holy grail mascara for years has been Max Factor Volume Couture, but since Max Factor is no longer going to be available in the US starting next year, I have been on the hunt for a new favorite, trying so many different drugstore mascaras it would make your head spin.
My results have been great (Prestige My Biggest Lashes), and also not so great. Basically what I look for in a mascara is volume, volume and more volume. Of course I want good length as well, but volume, and the ability to actually SEE my lashes is more important to me than lashes that will graze my eyebrows. Also, I actually
want a little clumpage. Don't get me wrong--I don't want spider lashes or anything crazy, but a little clumpage and thickness are exactly what I require to make my lashes visible. If the formula is too thin (usually what you get when you buy a mascara that "separates" lashes) then I'm afraid that, for me, that also means that it won't look like I'm wearing any mascara at all.
Also, I have oily skin so my dream mascara cannot run, smudge, or flake (I'm talkin' to you, L'Oreal) and it also cannot fade or disappear after a few hours (I'm talkin' to you, Rimmel). And if I can avoid it, I don't like to use waterproof formulas because I'm not big on using eye makeup remover unless I really have to.
So if you share any of my mascara requirements, read on, please!
Historically, I have not had good luck with Maybelline mascaras. Like a lot of you, my first mascara was
Great Lash, and I used it really because I just didn't know any better. It was so wet, and it ran and smeared miserably on me. Recently I tried
Maybelline Lash Stiletto, which has a formula that's waaaaaay too dry for me. Also, it didn't give me any volume whatsoever (I shouldn't have been surprised about that, really, because it's a lengthening formula). Next I tried
Maybelline XXL Volume + Length Washable Microfiber Mascara, which promised me 11x the volume. Yeah RIGHT. Even after applying the basecoat carefully and to every single lash, it provided no additional volume at all to my lashes. This one was probably worse than Lash Stiletto for me.
So right as I was about to quit Maybelline mascaras for good, I happened to watch
this video where Lauren Luke does a super clean and pretty eye look and mentions how much she adores
Maybelline Colossal Volum' Express Mascara (around the 8:20 mark in the video). She actually says that she is loving this mascara more than her beloved MAC mascara, which made think, "OK, she knows a thing or two about mascaras, and I'm really liking how this looks on
her. Dare I try ANOTHER Maybelline mascara?"
And ladies, that's when my love affair with
Colossal Volum' Express (retail: around $6) began. Let's take a look at some pics:
My eye, without mascara (see, I wasn't lying about having nonexistent lashes)
My eye, with two coats of Colossal Volum' Express
And here I am again with two coats of Colossal Volum' Express
For around six bucks at your local drugstore, I am telling you, this mascara is the bomb! It thickens, it lengthens, and it gives just enough clumpage to nonexistant lashes to make them actually stand out and be visible without looking like a gunky mess. Also, this formula doesn't smear, streak or flake on me, and it removes with my regular cleanser! I even like the brush--let me show you a pic of it in case a mascara's brush is a make-or-break deal for you.
I put some other brushes in this pic just for comparison:
As you can see, it's a little thinner than the Prestige brush, and not as long as the Lash Blast Length brush. In my book, this brush is just right.
Also, for all you ladies out there who apply mascara to their lower lashes, this one is fantastic for that! It separates and gives volume and length perfectly.
And one last thought: Don't be fooled by the first coat! Collossal Volum' really scared me when I was done with my first coat. It seemed like it was going to another letdown, but WOW, the second coat was amazing. For some reason, that second coat really makes your lashes pop, so don't give up or get frustrated after the first coat. Give it another coat and I think you might be pleasantly surprised.
Do you already use Maybelline Colossal Volum' Express? I'd love to hear your thoughts!