Comparison: Wet n Wild Prowler, Night Prowl and Petites Black Amethyst

A little while back, I purchased a few bottles of polish from the Wet n Wild Limited Edition Insomnia collection (click here for pics of the display). The first one I showed you was Mystic Blue, and now I'm going to show you Prowler.

But since I already own a few of these purple-microglitter-in-a-sheer-black-base types of colors, I thought I'd do a comparison.

Hum...they all look very similar, don't they? Heck, even the two Wet n Wild polishes both have the word "prowl" in the name! So let's see how they look on the nails:

All pics were taken with two coats and no base or top coat.

So what do you think? To be honest, I've never really liked Petites Black Amethyst. From the very first time I used it, it was streaky and sheer and never what I wanted it to be. But then along came WnW Night Prowl and my dreams came true! It's far more opaque and so easy to apply.

So how does the LE Wet n Wild Prowler compare to the core collection Wet n Wild Night Prowl? I'd say they're nearly identical. But I think Night Prowl dries to a slightly shinier finish, whereas Prowler dries to a more matte finish.

In my opinion, you definitely do not need all three of these shades. One will do the trick, and if I had to pick just one, I'd definitely go with Night Prowl.

Do you own any of these colors? What do you think of them?