Saturday, March 21, 2015

Review: Nonie Creme Colour Prevails Watercolour Eye Shadow Palette in Nude & Neutral

Continuing my reviews of the products I purchased from the new Nonie Creme Colour Prevails makeup brand (exclusive to Walgreens), today I'd like to show you the eyeshadow I purchased from the Walgreens site a few weeks ago.

PLEASE NOTE: The Nude & Neutral palette was the only palette available at the time of my purchase, but I see now that all three palettes are now available on the Walgreens site. You can check out the Marvelous Mattes palette HERE and the Smoky & Smudgy palette HERE. For more info about Nonie Creme (former founding Creative Director at Butter LONDON) and this brand, you can check out my Colour Prevails nail lacquer review HERE, and you can view the entire display, which is now popping up at Walgreens stores, HERE.

Nonie Creme Colour Prevails Watercolour Eye Shadow Palette in Nude & Neutral
(retail: $19, 0.32 oz)

Keep reading for my full review...

Before I get to the swatches, I want to talk about the pricing and value of this palette. There are eight shadows in this palette and each shadow is 0.04 oz. for a total of 0.32 oz. of product. The price of this palette is $19.

For perspective, here's a comparison (all palettes 0.32 oz):

Mass Market: 
Milani Runway Eyes Palette (now discontinued)
$8.49 for 0.32 oz.
Price per ounce: $26.53

Masstige: 
Nonie Creme Colour Prevails Watercolour Eye Shadow Palette
$19 for 0.32 oz.
Price per ounce: $59.37

Prestige: 
LORAC PRO Palette
$42 for 0.32 oz.
Price per ounce: $131.25

As you can see, the pricing of the Colour Prevails palette is about what you would expect for masstige. Not as economical as mass market, but not as much as prestige.


This palette is made of thick, die-cut cardboard with a glossy finish. The palette has an invisible magnetic closure.

Back of palette

Made in China



I tried this exact combo and it really is beautiful...

As you can see, this palette opens up like two butterfly wings, but it is also very much like an artist's palette. The one thing I do not like about the packaging is that you have to turn the palette around (facing the back of the palette) or the brush will fall out when you open it. In other words, if you open it while looking at the front of the palette (which would be the natural, instinctual way to open it), you'll find that the inside of the palette is upside-down, and the brush immediately falls to the ground. So you have to remember to turn it around and upside-down before you open it.

Here's a photo that illustrates what I'm trying to say:



Nyx Prismatic Eyeshadow: 0.43 oz.
Colour Prevails Eyeshadow (one pan): 0.40 oz.

I mentioned above that you get eight shadows in this palette, and that each shadow is 0.04 oz. But I'm more of a visual learner, so I thought it might help to see the pans next to a Nyx shadow that is 0.43 oz., just for perspective. As you can see, the pans in this palette aren't teeny-tiny. They're actually a good size when it comes to palettes (I've certainly seen smaller).


You also get a brush with this palette, which has a clear plastic handle. The bristles are quite soft on this brush, and it's not bad considering how lightweight it is (it's very, very light due to the plastic handle). I wouldn't use this as my primary eyeshadow brush, but it will certainly work in a pinch and it's much better quality than, say, the brushes that come with WnW trios or something like that. 


SWATCHES (NO PRIMER):












As you can see, these shadows aren't too impressive on bare skin, with the exception of the shade Jasper, which is absolutely dynamite without primer (super pigmented and metallic). So let's take a look at these shadows over Too Faced Shadow Insurance.

ALL SHADES OVER PRIMER (Too Faced Shadow Insurance):


Sand, Pebble, Chalk, Jasper


Fossil, Rock, Stone, Gravel

Over primer, the shimmers in this palette become so metallic that it was hard for me to photograph them without having them get completely washed out. Actually, the entire top row of shadows is fantastic over primer--much like a MAC, Urban Decay or LORAC type of formula. The bottom row isn't as impressive as the top row (Gravel, which is the dark purple matte with gold micro-glitter) was still patchy even over primer (not surprising since purple mattes in general can be problematic). But Fossil, Rock and Stone are not patchy--they're just not as pigmented as the four shades in the top row.

I thought you might like to see some comparisons to some other popular, higher-end neutrals, just for some perspective, so I did a few below.

COMPARISONS:

Colour Prevails Sand vs.
Urban Decay Sin and Urban Decay Burnout

Sand has more of a peach tone than UD Sin, and it's not as pink as UD Burnout. Notice how metallic Sand looks compared to the other two shades.

Colour Prevails Pebble vs.
Urban Decay Sidecar, MAC Satin Taupe and LORAC Smokey Topaz

Pebble is much cooler and more brown than all of the other shades above. 

Colour Prevails Chalk vs.
Urban Decay Virgin and Urban Decay Strange

Chalk is VERY similar to UD Virgin (I might even call it a dupe), and even though UD Strange is nowhere close to Chalk, I wanted to include it to show you that Chalk is definitely not a matte.

I'd also like to mention that, even though it's hard to see in my pics, ALL of the shadows in this palette contain micro-glitter (the sparkle is very, very fine--definitely not chunky). In some shades you can barely detect its presence unless you're in bright sunlight. 

Overall, I'm impressed with this palette for a few reasons. First of all, it feels like a lot of thought and care went into the color creation/selection. All eight shades feel very "modern" to me, for lack of a better word. I think we were just talking about how those new Neutrogena eyeshadow trios all contain the same ol' shades we've seen at the drugstore a zillion times, while the colors in this palette feel current and not just retreads of the same warm medium brown shimmers, etc. I am quite impressed with the shimmers in this palette. They are intense and metallic when worn over primer, and I actually haven't had any issues with any of these shades over primer, except for Gravel (which I explained earlier).

For the most part, the texture of these shadows is quite smooth and silky (some are SUPER silky, while others are good, but not mind-blowing). You may need to get them going a bit by rubbing with your brush a few times before the consistency really comes through, but I think that once you get in and start playing around with these shadows, you'll be as impressed as I am. They all blend easily, and the colors stay true and vivid over primer. I did experience a bit of fallout with a few shades, and a few shades are a tiny bit powdery, but overall the quality is there. Staying power is great over primer as well--I can get 6-7 hours of wear before I start to notice slight fading and creasing. 

FINAL VERDICT: Is this new drugstore palette worth $19? I think that depends on what shades you already have in your stash, and how much you love neutrals. I love that a palette like this is available at the drugstore level, filled with modern colors and shades that all work together so nicely. You could easily use just this palette on a weekend getaway and be good to go for daytime and evening. I think that if Walgreens runs sales on the Colour Prevails line moving forward (or you have a bunch of Balance Rewards saved up), this one's worth considering if you like shimmery neutrals. I'm not sure I'd pay full price though, because, well, look at the name of my blog. I don't like paying $20 for anything at the drugstore! That said, I don't regret this purchase because you know I'm always drawn to shades like this, and the quality is quite good (especially when worn over primer).

In case you missed it at the top of my post, you can check out the Marvelous Mattes palette HERE (I really want to try that one next) and the Smoky & Smudgy palette HERE. And you can check out the entire Nonie Creme Colour Prevails display HERE.

The products featured in this post were purchased with personal funds. For more information, click here.
SHARE:

23 comments

  1. I dont know how I feel about a $19 drugstore palette... hmmm

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, as I mentioned above, it's the EXACT size as a LORAC PRO palette (both are 0.32 oz), and for less than half the price, but when I see $19 at Walgreens it makes me twitchy. I really hope they run some good sales, because I want to try the all matte one next, but I want it for less than $19! :)

      Delete
    2. I think these eyeshadows are quite lovely especially with the primer and the packaging is very cute. I definitely hope they have some good sales soon, because I agree with you, $19 for a drugstore palette is pretty high. Interested in the matte palette as well.

      Delete
    3. I really hope they have some good sales too. I would definitely purchase the others if there was a BOGOFREE. :)

      Delete
  2. The price doesn't scare me.. just paid almost that much for Loreal.. but the fact that they are all shimmer/glitter and the pigmentation is so poor does. I expect them to get better with primer, but they are practically non existent without it. The packaging looks really awkward to handle and store as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. There's an all matte option. :) I should add that I did wear all of the shadows without primer during my testing and I was able get get vibrancy that you don't see in my swatches on bare skin. To be fair, it's different when you're applying to your eyes and layering shades, vs just one swipe on bare skin. But I certainly understand what you mean. Jasper is the only shade here that has incredible, one swipe pigmentation on bare skin.

      As for the packaging, the overall palette itself is not big or thick...it was much more compact in person than I thought it would be, given that there is a lot of empty space between each pan. I hope that helps a little bit!

      Delete
    2. If you are suggesting "Marveloys Mattes" is the "all matte option" you should do your research - every single shadow in that palette is shimmer. Not a single matte. Ugh.

      Delete
  3. The fact that the colors on the packaging look nothing like the colors in the pans is rather annoying. Fossil looks like it should be a dark olive green when the pan and swatch show it as a brownish gold at best. The packaging also looks way too bulky for the amount of product given.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That threw me off too! Before I opened it, I definitely thought there was a green shade in this I palette, but as you mentioned, it's a brownish gold. I actually like the shade, but if I had purchased it in-store specifically thinking there was green here, I would be really disappointed.

      I mentioned in my comment above that the entire palette actually isn't bulky (it's thin and a lot smaller than I thought it was based on the pics online). It looks bulky in pics because there's a lot of empty space between each pan, but it really doesn't feel bulky when you're using it. The shape is unique for sure, but not cumbersome (to me, at least). I do wish it contained a mirror though! I hope that helps. :)

      Delete
  4. I just can't get past the packaging. The colors are pretty though.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I understand! I've heard from others who aren't a big fan of the packaging design of this line. :)

      Delete
  5. Pricy! I am not fan of the design I pass!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'm not sure about something Made in China near my eyes. Would rather pay a little more for higher quality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I understand the concern, but that's not an issue for me personally. If you use Wet n Wild, elf, Tarte, Too Faced, NYC, Sephora brand, etc then there's a good chance you've already used eye products made in China. Also, some Nyx shadows are made in China...I'm sure there are other popular brands I'm forgetting. :)

      Delete
  7. How do some of the shades compare to the two new L'Oreal La Nude Palettes (and have I missed your full review of those)? thx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You didn't miss it...I'm actually working on my review of both palettes right now! :)

      Delete
  8. Guess im the minority here, but I'm pretty intrigued. I hope the smokey palette is as good as this one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lol yeah, I understand the negative feedback given the pricing, but I really do like this palette...i just HOPE that Walgreens offers us some good sales so that I can try the others. I'd love to know what you think if you get the matte one. :)

      Delete
  9. It's posts like this that make me appreciate your blog and all the work that goes into it...I would never even know about this otherwise...the makeup aisles can be pretty overwhelming, and you're a guide! :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Arathael, you have no idea how much that means to me. Thank you SO much. xo

      Delete
  10. I think these would look cute hanging on a cup hook on a wall in my bathroom. I saw them at my Walgreen's and they even had one open behind the counter to swatch. They are very, very charming! I don't think I could buy one without some kind of sale either though.

    ReplyDelete
  11. OK, the more I read about Nonie and these products, the more I want to try them. After reading from several people what a fail the new Smoky UD palette is, I'd like to give the Colour Prevails Smoky & Smudgy palette a try. Also some of the nail polishes. Walgreens, here I come.

    Thank you for being the first blogger I know to tell us about this company!

    ReplyDelete

I love and encourage comments here at Nouveau Cheap, and I do not censor comments unless they violate my comment policy, which you can view here.

Please refrain from comments that contain:
• Links to your own blog or website
• Advertisements or referral links

Thanks very much for your help in keeping this a spam-free zone.

© 2009- Nouveau Cheap. All rights reserved.
BLOGGER TEMPLATE MADE BY pipdig