There are some makeup items on sale for $5 each (regularly $23 - $25) but you kind of have to poke around the makeup section and go category by category to find them (most of the $5 items are in the face makeup sections). But there are some other things on sale in the color cosmetics sections such as Colorglide Shine Lip Colors for $6.25 (regularly $12.50). Also, the Slanted Kabuki Brush is $14 (regularly $28).
And don't forget that The Body Shop is running another one of their B3G3FREE offers right now--this is sitewide on all products but it does NOT apply to sale merchandise. Everyday free shipping on orders of $50 or more.
Thanks again, Sammie, for the great tip!