Check the Nordstrom Beauty Sale Page and
Macy's Beauty Sale Page for
New Deals Daily with Free Shipping

Saturday, December 12, 2015

Swatches & First Impressions: Too Faced Chocolate Bon Bons Eye Shadow Palette

I received the Too Faced Chocolate Bon Bons Eye Shadow Palette about 1-1/2 weeks ago for review, but I wanted to get this post up as quickly as I could since I'm guessing it will be back in stock at HSN any minute now (where you can grab it at a discount; click here for the details about that). So even though this isn't a formal review (I test everything I review here for a minimum of two weeks), I do have some opinions about it after using it for about a week. So hopefully this will help you if you're on the fence about getting it!

PLEASE NOTE: This palette retails for $49 (total net weight: 0.56 oz.). Although it is currently out of stock at HSN (keep checking HERE for restock info), it's available now on the Too Faced website HERE (free shipping through the holidays). As of the time of this post, this palette is also available exclusively for VIB and VIB Rouge status holders at Sephora HERE (you can use your VIB Holiday Loyalty Rewards if you're reading this before 12/15!). I'm guessing that this palette will also be available at Ulta soon (as of the time of this post, it is not yet listed on the Ulta site; you can check this link in case it becomes available after I publish this blog post). Hopefully we see it at Ulta before the 20% off coupon expires.

Bulk Made in USA, Assembled in Dominican Republic
(click to enlarge for ingredients)

Click to enlarge

All shadows swatched on bare skin (no primer):

Almond Truffle, Cashew Chew, Cotton Candy, Café au Lait

Dark Truffle, Pecan Praline, Totally Fetch

Sprinkles, Molasses Chip, Malted, Bordeaux

Mocha, Black Currant, Earl Grey

Highlight shades (rectangular pans):

Satin Sheets, Divinity

Again, all of my swatches above were done on bare skin (no primer). I swirled my (clean) finger into each pan once, and then swiped twice for each color. As you can see, most of these colors have good pigmentation without primer--and they come alive WITH primer. My first four swatches (the lightest colors in the palette) appear quite light in my photos, but that has more to do with them blending into my actual skintone, rather than the pigmentation. Almond Truffle (taupey-rose matte) is actually quite pigmented in person, and it's a gorgeous transition shade. My photo does not do it justice.


With the exception of Bordeaux, which is a bit stiff/dry, the mattes in this palette are all smooth, silky, pigmented, and easy to work with. Absolutely no complaints here but again, Bordeaux is a bit dry and stiff for my taste.


As is the case with most Too Faced shimmers, you won't be disappointed with these if you're a shimmer lover. Most shades here are so shimmery, they're borderline metallic. I did run into a little trouble with Totally Fetch, which was a bit crumbly for me. So proceed with caution there, because you'll probably experience some fallout. Also, I found Black Currant to be a little dry/stiff, but it "loosened up" a bit after a few uses. Sometimes I find that stiffer shadows just need to get going a bit with your brush before they reach their full potential. I also want to mention that Sprinkles totally surprised me. In the pan, it looks like a standard light pink shimmer. But in certain lights, there's a lovely coral flash to it that my camera didn't really pick up. If you get this palette, pay special attention that one--it's so much prettier in person.

Additional Thoughts:

I own the original Too Faced Chocolate Bar Palette as well as the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Bar Palette, and I don't see any glaringly obvious repeats in the Bon Bon Palette. I feel like there are a few similar shades, but it seems that some of the mattes in those palettes have shimmer counterparts in this palette, and vice versa. So if you really like a color in one of the "bar" palettes but wish you could get it in a different finish, you might find that here. If you'd like, after the holidays I'd be happy to do a full comparison with swatches of all three palettes side by side. Just leave a comment below and let me know if you'd like to see that.

Preliminary Verdict:

Well obviously, this palette is adorable. But beyond looks, I find that there's a nice balance between cool, warm, and neutral tones here. This palette does favor shimmer lovers though, since there are ten shimmers here and only six mattes. Overall, even though I own the Chocolate Bar and Semi-Sweet palettes, I would purchase this palette because, with the exception of Totally Fetch (which is way out of my comfort zone), all of these shades totally appeal to me and are well within my own personal comfort zone. Also, on most days, I tend to use the palette that's closest to me on my vanity (hashtag: lazy girl) and I like that I don't find myself searching my stash for other shades when I'm working with this palette. Everything's here and it's easy to create some lovely looks using just these colors. I don't think that there are any shades here that are totally revolutionary or unique, but I like that there are just so many colors that appeal to me in one palette. And with the exception of a few shades that are a little problematic, I think they're all at the level we've come to expect from Too Faced.

Oh! And how could I forget that, as is the case with the "bar" palettes, this one also smells of delicious cocoa powder (it actually contains cocoa powder). I sometimes open these palettes just to sniff them, and this one's no exception. Because I'm weird like that.

Bonus Pics:

Occasionally, brands include little gifts along with review samples. As you know, I don't usually include pics of those little extras in my posts, but when they're super cute, I can't resist. When I received my Bon Bon Palette, Too Faced included this Champagne & Strawberries Dark Chocolate Bar in the package.

Look at this label:

Adorable, right? I haven't actually opened it yet, so I can't comment on the flavor (I'm saving it for my birthday tomorrow).

A sample of this product was given to Nouveau Cheap for editorial purposes, either directly from the manufacturer or from the agency that works on behalf of the manufacturer. All reviews on are the honest opinion of its author and editorial samples do not, in any way, affect the outcome of product reviews. For more information, click here.


  1. Happy bday if you're reading this tomorrow! Or early bday if you're reading it today!
    Yes to swatches and comparisons please! Thanks G!

    1. Thank you so much, Isaza! I am going to try to take a little break from the blog tomorrow for the b-day, so I'm glad I saw this tonight! xo

      PS: I'll try to post a big comparison of all three palettes right after the holiday craziness. I wish I could do it sooner, but it's nuts right now! :)

  2. Happy Birthday, G!! Take some time to celebrate! :) I would love to see a comparison of all three after the holidays.

  3. Happy Birthday G!!!...Thank you for being the Best Beauty Blogger..We appreciate you for all you do...Enjoy your day :)

  4. I've gotten some really good deals because of your blog!! Thanks for the hard work!

  5. G. so glad you were born as I have followed you for a few years now and you brighten my life! Hope your birth day is a wonderful celebration!

  6. Happy Birthday G !!! Hope you have a fabulous day. XOXO

  7. That is the perfect birthday treat! Have a great bday :)

  8. Happy Birthday! Hope you have a great day! Glad you liked this palette! My Choclate Bar Palette is split in two and I need to show it a little love... so I'm tempted to buy this palette... but I'm going to resist! That candy bar is so adorable! I love that they find a way to put Clover on everything!

  9. Happy birthday! You're amazing and thank you at everything you do.

  10. Happy Birfday!!!! And I would love to see a side by side of the three palettes, when you have time. xoxo

  11. Happy Birthday from Texas! 🎈🎁🎊🎉🎂

  12. Happy Birthday, G! Enjoy your special day!

  13. Happy birthday! And yes, please post comparisons with the other chocolate palettes if you ever have time.

  14. Happy birthday, G! What an adorble palette! Thanks for all the hard work you do for us 💜

  15. Happy birthday!! Thanks so much for everything you do!

  16. Happy Birthday, hope you have a delicious day!!

  17. Happy Birthday! May you have a wonderful and blessed day today on your special day. I can't wait to receive my TF Chocolate Bar Bon Bons palette. Seeing the swatches gets me even more excited to get my hands on this palette. I LOVE how these palettes smell like chocolate! The label for the chocolate bar bonus gift you received is adorable!

  18. Happy Birthday, I hope you have a wonderful one!

  19. Happy Birthday, G!!! Sagittarius Rock!! Enjoy your special day... We all appreciate everything you do for us!! I'm the one that needs to step away from here for a bit!! My wallet is screaming! LMAO!! Eat cake for all of us!!

  20. Happy Early Birthday from the Northeast! Thank you for all the work you put into this blog for all of us readers. I hope you have a fabulous day!

  21. Happy Birthday! I hope you're having a wonderful day! Thank you for all your hard work this holiday season. It's been a big help to me.

  22. Happy birthday G! Those shadows look amazing and yes it will be great if you can compare the 3 Chocolate Bars...after all Holidays' craziness, there will be St. Valentines! 😉

  23. Happy birthday!
    That palette looks so cute. I like the mix of neutrals with a few pops of bright.

  24. Thank you all so VERY, VERY much for all of the incredibly sweet birthday wishes! You made my day! xo

    PS: I'll be sure to do a big comparison of all three palettes after the holidays!

  25. Happy Birthday to the best blogger on the planet Earth!!!!!!!!!!!

    1. Awww, Peteena, you are too kind! Thank you SO MUCH for that! Hugs & Kisses, G. xo

  26. Hi! My name is Scheherazade and I wanted to ask if later on when you get the time if you could do a too face chocolate bon bon eye shadow dupe comparison with 252 or 88 Coastal Scents eye shadow. Thankyou. ^_^

  27. I personally would love to see swatches and comparisons of all 3 because I feel based on these pics that Champagne Truffle and Satin Sheets look some what familiar, but I'm not entirely sure because of I don't own this palette just the original.

  28. Hey there! Have you had time to do the side by side swatches of the Chocolate Bar and Bon Bon palettes? I'm trying to find it on your blog and can't....


I love and encourage comments here at Nouveau Cheap, and I do not censor comments unless they violate my comment policy, which you can view here.

Please refrain from comments that contain:
• Links to your own blog or website
• Advertisements or referral links

Thanks very much for your help in keeping this a spam-free zone.

© 2009- Nouveau Cheap. All rights reserved.