From the Walgreens ad for week of 5/11 - 5/17
ALL MONTH LONG (now through 5/31): select Wet n Wild Fergie products are 25% off. I believe this includes items that regularly retail from between $3.49 - $5.99. So this is why those of you who have tried to buy the Summer 2014 Limited Edition To Reflect Shimmer Palettes have not been able to get the discount (those retail for $6.99).
THIS WEEK ONLY (now through 5/17): select Wet n Wild Fergie products are 40% off and when you buy 2 qualifying products, you'll receive 500 points on your card. Again, I believe this includes items that regularly retail from between $3.49 - $5.99. Now some of you have said that you did not get the 40% off on limited edition items, so I'm wondering if you were trying to buy the Limited Edition To Reflect Shimmer Palettes, which are $6.99 and do not qualify for this sale. The items that fall between $3.49 and $5.99 should ring up for 40% off this week only (they'll revert back to 25% off on 5/18, through 5/31).
ALL MONTH LONG (now through 5/31): select Wet n Wild (NOT FERGIE) items are 30% off and 40% off. For example, Megaslicks Balm Stains, Megarocks Nail Polishes, Coverall products, Glassy Glosses, Megashield Lip Colors, Coloicon Bronzers and Megavolume mascara are 30% off, while the Megaliner Liquid Eyeliners, H20 Proof Liquid Eyeliners and Perfect Pair Eye Wands are 40% off. You can verify this yourself by checking the prices online here (there are more items on sale than what I listed above).
The biggest issue that seems to be popping up is that Fergie products that should be 40% off this week are either coming up 25% off in the system or not on sale at all. If the Fergie items you're trying to buy have a regular retail price of between $3.49 and $5.99 and they're not coming up 40% off this week, you can try showing the cashier the sale ad (see image above from this week's circular) and asking if they can manually override the price in the system. This is at the store's discretion, so there's no guarantees this will work (but it doesn't hurt to try).
Thanks again to several of you for the tips, input and advice. I really, really appreciate it!