Dupe Alert: Halloween 2013 Fantasy Makers by Wet n Wild Paper Lashes

A few weeks ago, I showed you the big Halloween 2013 Fantasy Makers display that's now popping up in Kmart stores. In this display, there are some paper lashes, and I've since heard from several readers that these paper lashes are also showing up at CVS and Rite Aid (and probably other retailers too).

But what you might not know is that there's a dupe (two dupes, actually) lurking in this lash collection! Huge thanks to reader Angela (_makeuploverx0 on Instagram) for this one. Angela spotted an exact dupe in this collection and was kind enough to share some pics. Take a look!

image credit: Angela for Nouveau Cheap

Fantasy Makers by Wet n Wild Bewitching Eyes Eyelashes in Woodland Dreams

(retail: $4.99 at CVS)

image credit: Angela for Nouveau Cheap

Fantasy Makers paper lashes in Woodland Dreams

As you can see, the Woodland Dreams design contains deer, butterflies and branches. Take a look at this set of Paperself lashes (below), which Angela purchased at Sephora two years ago. Angela said she paid $13 for these (on sale) two years ago, and they're still available on the Paperself website for £12.50GBP (exchange rate as of the time of this post is $19.74US):

image credit: Angela for Nouveau Cheap 

Paperself paper lashes in Deer and Butterfly 

And now here they are, side by side:

image credit: Angela for Nouveau Cheap

Exact dupes!

The Paperself lashes have curled a little bit so that you can't see all of the butterflies but if you look closely, you'll see that they're identical to the Wet n Wild lashes. Wow!

And as I was writing this post, reader Candice shared this photo of one of the other styles in the Fantasy Makers Bewitching Eyes Collection (she spotted these at CVS as well):

image credit: Candice for Nouveau Cheap

Fantasy Makers by Wet n Wild Bewitching Eyes Eyelashes in Entangled
($4.99 at CVS)

And guess what? This design is ALSO a dupe for the Paperself design called Spider! I think there are only two paper lash designs in the Fantasy Makers lashes collection, but I could be wrong (if you've seen other paper lash designs in the display, please do let us know!).

If you're a fan of fun, whimsical lashes and you're on a budget, I suggest you head out to CVS, Kmart, etc. and look for these Fantasy Makers paper lashes ASAP (before the Halloween season is over)!

Thanks so very much, Angela, for the fantastic dupe alert. It is much appreciated! And thanks to Candice for the pic of one of the other designs in this collection--it's great that this one's a dupe too!