Thanks so much to reader Rae for this one!
Right now on the America Eagle website HERE, you can get the original Make Up Eraser for $12 (full retail price: $20). Plus, free standard shipping on all orders right now as well. As you probably know, this exact product retails for $20 at Sephora!
You know, I tried a similar product a few years ago and it really did work. I haven't tried the original though--have you? This would be a nice way to get it if you've always wanted one (or even as a fun stocking stuffer).
Thanks again, Rae, for the awesome tip!